Not long ago, a close friend of mine came to me with a troubling dilemma.
Her concern began when choosing between Benjamin Moore Alabaster vs Sherwin Williams Alabaster.
The glaring concern that stood out to me was that although Benjamin Moore and Sherwin Williams Alabaster were very similar, they had a significant difference in their undertones.
Where BM Alabaster showed pink, SW Alabaster was creamy yellow.
This was my immediate concern and led me to wonder how to help her pick.
She wanted a transitional look for her modern condo and was unwilling to budge from alabaster.
When I further questioned her interest in the color, she seemed vested in the popular commotion around Sherwin Williams Alabaster 7008.
Yet wanted to work with a white that held more unpredictability like Benjamin Moore Alabaster.
This following content is curated to help highlight how we worked around Benjamin Moore Alabaster versus Sherwin Williams Alabaster.
I will lay out the curious details on both whites and make a step by step comparison between the two.
We will also explore other whites, see what will parallel them as an equivalent along with coordinating hues with the hope that you will find which Alabaster suits your taste and your space.
About Benjamin Moore Alabaster
Benjamin Moore Alabaster is a bright off white that carries pink and gray undertones.
It is officially described as ‘a fresh, youthful white with a flattering touch of pink.’
If you fear a flash of yellow in your white, Alabaster by Benjamin Moore is the one to choose.
Up to this point, your task is simple.
But the trouble begins once you realize that Benjamin Moore offers more than one Alabaster and features more than one color with the same characteristics.
Officially Benjamin Moore Alabaster OC-129 and Benjamin Moore Alabaster 876 have the same LRV of 85.08. They are known interchangeably.
Yet the confusion continues as another BM Atrium White OC-145 shares similar traits to the two alabasters.
Your task lengthens as Atrium White PM-13 in the same category emerges with an LRV of 87.04.
Leaving all these aside, the sophisticated appeal of BM Alabaster makes it a color that suits multiple designs.
It has a warm glow that avoids being creamy or stark and is best suited to cozy spaces.
| Benjamin Moore Alabaster | Details |
| Also Known As | Alabaster OC-129, Alabaster 876, Atrium White PM-13, Atrium White OC-145 |
| Color Family | White |
| LRV | Mainly 85.08 and PM-13 with 87.04 |
| Hex Value | #F2EEE7 |
| HSL | 38°, 30%, 93% |
| Wavelength | 576.7 nm |
| Undertone | Pink and gray |
| Best Used As | Exterior, walls, cabinets, trims, doors |
| RBG | 242, 238, 231 |
About Sherwin Williams Alabaster (7008)
Alabaster SW 7008 is a light and balanced white with an LRV of 82.
It has a creamy warmth without an extreme flash of yellow that makes it a bright white without the starkness.
I personally find Sherwin Williams Alabaster to be a great color to work with since it harmonizes easily with all kinds of decor.
It is a warm off white that has been established as the Sherwin Williams Color of the year 2016.
The yellow undertone of SW Alabaster keeps it from feeling too clinical while the gray balances the yellow to keep it neutral.
I felt the impact of its warm glow under direct sunlight and noted that it becomes creamier under warm light.
You will find that alabaster will open up narrow spaces but do keep in mind that dimness will make its gray come out.
| Sherwin Williams Alabaster 7008 | Details |
| Color Family | White |
| LRV | 82 |
| Hex Value | #EDEAE0 |
| HSL | 46°, 27%, 90% |
| Wavelength | 574.06 nm |
| Undertone | Yellow and gray |
| Best Used As | Exterior, trim, cabinetry, walls |
| RBG | 237, 234, 224 |
What is the difference between Benjamin Moore Alabaster and Sherwin Williams Alabaster?
As I began breaking down the details of Benjamin Moore Alabaster vs Sherwin Williams Alabaster, my dear friend gave me a look that said “I hear you but I don’t understand you.”
Therefore, the following content has been made to clarify how these alabasters are different.
We will look at their LRVs, undertone and lighting to figure how they appear.
My goal is to help you work with these off whites by systematically breaking down the behaviour of the two colors.
I hope that you will be able to use this information for your benefit to choose between Benjamin Moore or Sherwin Williams Alabaster.
Let us begin!
LRV
Benjamin Moore alabaster versus Sherwin Williams alabaster are warm off whites that will brighten up any space they are used in.
Though the difference in LRVs affects how much light one color reflects.
Let us start with Sherwin Williams Alabaster 7008 that has an LRV of 82 which makes it look close to a clean white in well lighted rooms.
I find that it gives off an eye-catching, almost creamy glow that doesn’t hurt the eyes.
Similarly, BM Alabaster OC-129 and Benjamin Moore Alabaster 876, both come with a high LRV of 85.08.
But this minute difference makes them a brighter white that mutes SW Alabaster when seen side to side.
I saw that BM Alabaster does have a pinkish sheen at times but it usually looks close to a bright white in sunlit rooms.
Duly note that BM Atrium White PM-13 will glow even brighter when compared to the formerly discussed whites due to its LRV of 87.04.
Undertone
When I work with colors, I always rely on getting their samples.
My friend was rather taken by this idea and we worked on procuring Benjamin Moore Alabaster and Sherwin Williams Alabaster to get a better clue about their appearance.
You will get the best results through pasting them on a white wall in a room of choice.
It pleased me to be right once we saw the blushy glow of BM Alabaster to the mild concern of my friend.
These alabasters come with an undertone of pink and gray that tenderly warms the senses.
SW Alabaster worked wonderfully as a creamy white that didn’t give off too much yellow.
It has a temper of yellow and gray undertones that balances each other to feel neutral.
How Light Affects It
I am always astounded by how colors behave in different lighting conditions.
A behaviour that is especially enhanced by their undertones.
Alabaster Benjamin Moore undertones of pink and gray keep it from looking pale in sunlit rooms.
Next, I found it to look a touch gray in cool lighting that highlighted its neutral property.
I was assured of its shifting appearance only because of how light and airy it continued to feel no matter the change in lighting.
Alabaster Sherwin Williams undertones on the other hand are a blend of yellow and gray which gives it a classic appearance that suits most tastes.
I could note its warming brightness in southern rooms which was contrasted by its neutral gray appearance when the light dimmed.
When To Make The Most Of BM Alabaster and SW Alabaster
Benjamin Moore Alabaster vs Sherwin Williams Alabaster are warm whites that appear different due to their undertones and LRVs, but will suit any look of your home with their bright appearance.
Benjamin Moore Alabaster 876 / OC-129 are great additions to the home to nurture a cozy and cohesive look throughout.
You can make the most of it by using it with warm woody hues, darker accents and organic materials like linen.
It is a color that best compliments cozy spaces to make them feel more inviting and comfortable.
Sherwin Williams Alabaster 7008 is a proper off white that warms without being too glaring on the eyes.
I find it to be an ideal trim color that matches dark and bold hues, especially best for highlighting architectural structures that favor arches and mouldings.
For a more natural appeal, you can pair it with linen and rattan textures, plus woody and brass accents.
| Color | Benjamin Moore Alabaster | Sherwin Williams Alabaster 7008 |
| LRV | 85.08 | 82 |
| Undertone | Pink and gray | Yellow and gray |
| Feel | Tender, airy and cozy | Inviting, warm and airy |
| Natural Light | A soft glow of white in bright light or south facing rooms A subtle gray or beige in cool light or north facing rooms | An airy creamy white in bright light or south facing rooms A neutral lightness without being too dull in cool light or north facing rooms |
| Artificial Light | Warm bulbs expose it to a pinkish creaminess Cool bulbs make it appear neutral | Creamier under warm bulbs A balanced neutral white under cool bulbs |
| Best Use | Bedrooms, living rooms, kitchens, bathrooms, exterior | Exterior, living rooms, hallways, bedrooms, kitchens, bathrooms |
Where To Use BM Alabaster vs SW Alabaster?
A new start is full of challenges and this was true for my friend and I as we began work to pick and define how Benjamin Moore Alabaster vs Sherwin Williams Alabasters looked in her modern condo.
We mapped out the lighting in her home and were set to work immediately.
The following discussion will highlight how Alabaster Benjamin Moore undertones and Alabaster Sherwin Williams undertones work in a setting with transitional designs.
Do note that they will not be used together as they do not pair well.
Let us begin by looking at her south facing living room.
Living room
After a lengthy observation and struggle with Benjamin Moore or Sherwin Williams Alabaster, she went with SW Alabaster 7008 for her living room.
It was the right choice as the living room was south-facing and it made the room open up with a warmth that did not drown us.
Her living space gave me a warm and inviting feeling.
Sherwin Williams Alabaster melted into the backdrop of the woody elements of the room and set such an airy mood that I wanted to immediately roll up on her linen couch.
If you object to the slight yellow of SW Alabaster, then I suggest you pick the warm balance of BM Alabaster OC-129 or 876.
If you want a tender and cozy vibe that does not suffocate and is brighter than SW Alabaster, Benjamin Moore Alabaster will not disappoint.
Bedroom
The important part of decorating your own bedroom is making the most of its coziness as we all seek a restful escape from the world.
We were able to use each version of BM and SW Alabaster for her two bedrooms.
The Alabaster Benjamin Moore undertones of pink and gray manifested an airy freshness in her west facing bedroom.
Its LRV of 85.04 makes it highly reflective so we settled for a matte finish that kept it from feeling too washed out.
The lingering appeal of pink and the mostly white cover of this color worked as a sophisticated backdrop to the transitional designs and clean furnishings.
On the other hand, we used Sherwin Williams Alabaster for her east facing bedroom as it could retain its off white appeal in cool light even with a lower LRV of 82.
I preferred the classy mood it depicted against the natural wood and transitional decor.
In the end, the choice of where you use them is up to you but you must consider the issue of lighting that we have already discussed.
Bathroom
When working with Benjamin Moore or Sherwin Williams Alabaster, it was hard to pick the better of the two as they worked well as bathroom colors.
Similar to the bedrooms, we went with BM Alabaster OC-129 or 876 for the west facing bathroom.
It was an immediate hit since it lighted up the space when paired with the accent wall and marble counters.
You should definitely go with this for its clean sophistication.
The other bathroom was painted with SW Alabaster 7008 and immediately became a safe retreat akin to a spa.
This alabaster does not lose its warmth in the east facing light and is elevated by warm metals and organic decor.
While Sherwin Williams Alabaster suits cool lighted bathrooms since they do not lean gray, make sure to consider brighter spaces for Benjamin Moore Alabaster since they will look dull in cool light.
Cabinets
The abundant southern light of my friend’s kitchen called for more attention for the choice of cabinet color.
Between the refreshing openness of Benjamin Moore Alabaster and the cozy welcome of Sherwin Williams Alabaster, we went with the second one.
You can work with Benjamin Moore Alabaster 876 / OC-129 by pairing it with cool neutral grays, whites and marble.
The combination feels bright and sunkissed without the dinginess of yellow.
On the flip side, the Alabaster SW 7008 we chose, reflected a beige white that felt clean and widened the space of the kitchen.
To add a warm contrast, the lower cabinets were colored Dakota Wheat SW 9023 which matched the white quartz countertops and matte black hardware.
So you can go with Sherwin Williams Alabaster for a subtle warmth that feels airy or Benjamin Moore Alabaster for a gentler white with a sophisticated pink hue.
Exterior
Benjamin Moore or Sherwin Williams Alabaster will both reward you with a welcoming visual of white as a dominant exterior.
The two are warm off whites that differ on points of LRV and undertone so you have to study how they appear from day to night before deciding.
Alabaster Benjamin Moore manifests a modern contemporary feel with an almost true white look in daylight due to its LRV of 85.04.
It slowly shifts from a fresh white with a pinkish glow to a gentle gray as the sun sets.
Alabaster Sherwin Williams 7008 with yellow and gray reflects a classic white that does not look washed out.
It feels cozy and bright in daylight with an LRV of 82 without the starkness.
You can pair both alabasters with wood accents and natural stone or bold blacks to create maximum contrast.
Benjamin Moore Alabaster VS Sherwin Williams Alabaster VS Other Whites
In case Benjamin Moore Alabaster vs Sherwin Williams Alabaster are complicating your search, let me provide a list of whites that will be good alternatives for you.
All whites differ in minute details of LRVs and undertones which affect how they appear.
Their appearance, you will see, is critical to setting the right mood and vibe for your space.
The following discussion is aimed at giving you an idea about the differing tones of whites.
Let us have a look at the following whites!
Sherwin Williams Greek Villa 7551
Greek Villa SW 7551 has an LRV of 84 which makes it a bright off white.
It has a subtle buttery warmth due to its gray and yellow undertone that gives it an extra soft vibe.
With Sherwin Williams alabaster vs greek villa, the first is a touch more muted given its LRV of 82 while the other is a brighter beige in comparison.
Their similar undertones give them a warm feel where both will work to give your space an inviting tranquility.
When we consider Benjamin Moore Alabaster OC-129 or 876 against the two above, it reflects the most light with an LRV of 85.04 which makes it the brightest of the three.
The undertone of pink and gray is another key factor that differentiates it as it will not show the subtle yellow seen in SW alabaster and greek villa.
Benjamin Moore White Dove OC-17
BM White Dove OC-17 comes with an LRV of 83.16 which aligns it between BM Alabaster and SW Alabaster.
It has a light brush of yellow and gray undertone that leaves it feeling close to a clean soft white.
Now if we compare Benjamin moore white dove vs sherwin williams alabaster, the first carries a luminosity that is cleaner than SW 7008 alabaster that has an LRV of 82.
These warm off whites carry a similar softness that is both classic and fresh.
With Benjamin Moore alabaster vs white dove, the first has a brightness of 85.04 LRV that outclasses the latter.
You can go with BM alabaster for a clean richness that carries an elegant invite of pink or work with the other two for the cozy openness of bright beige.
Benjamin Moore Swiss Coffee OC-45
BM Swiss Coffee OC-45 is a creamy off white with an LRV of 81.91.
It comes with undertones of gray, yellow and a dose of green that blend together to create a neutral white without obvious starkness.
Benjamin moore swiss coffee vs sherwin williams alabaster may look similar but placed side to side, you will notice that SW alabaster is creamier.
The gray and green in Swiss Coffee mutes the butteriness to make it a balanced white with an embracing stillness.
Benjamin Moore Alabaster vs swiss coffee on the other hand differ not only in brightness but also in how the hues appear.
BM alabaster has an LRV of 85.04 that suitably creates warmth and lightness with its undertone of pink and gray.
While Swiss coffee has a neutral balance that makes it more adaptable in comparison.
Benjamin Moore Seapearl OC-19
BM Seapearl OC-19 has a depth of gray and beige with a brush of green that softens it from appearing too yellow.
Its LRV of 76.43 makes it the least bright in comparison to Benjamin Moore alabaster versus Sherwin Williams alabaster and changes with the lighting.
When considering Benjamin moore seapearl vs sherwin williams alabaster, note that the former shifts between gray and beige while the latter appears more balanced as a soft white.
On the other hand, Benjamin Moore alabaster 876 or OC-129 has a similar unpredictability with flashes of pink but behaves more like a soft bright white due to its high LRV of 85.04.
You can go with BM alabaster for the most luminosity or choose Seapearl for its grayish depth that suitably blends with the outdoor foliage.
Benjamin Moore Calm OC-22
BM Calm OC-22 has an LRV of 75.83 that gives it a depth that is saturated with purple, gray and brown undertones.
These hues melt together to give it a sometimes cool, sometimes warm off white that soothes and creates a peaceful atmosphere.
If we look at Benjamin moore calm vs sherwin williams alabaster side to side, the first is immediately the most muted when compared to the other which has an LRV of 82.
Alabaster SW 7008 will lend you a bright creamy warmth while BM Calm will pull you into a quiet calm of lavender gray radiance.
BM Alabaster on the other hand has the brightest glow when compared to the above two due to its higher LRV of 85.04.
You can go with Benjamin Moore alabaster if you want a cleaner look while BM Calm offers a similar but deeper hue of pink.
Benjamin Moore Simply White OC-117
BM Simply White OC-117 with an LRV of 89.52 is close to a clean crisp white which has been established as Benjamin Moore’s color of the year 2016.
It has a small hint of yellow that keeps it from appearing clinical while giving it a soft warmth which makes it a popular house color.
Benjamin moore simply white vs sherwin williams alabaster are breaths apart where the latter feels more toned down with an LRV of 82.
You can go with the true white of BM Simply White for its adaptability or the creamy beige of SW alabaster for its warmth.
We will note that Benjamin Moore alabaster OC-129 lies in between the above two in brightness and carries an equally warm appeal with an elegant touch of pink.
So pick BM alabaster for its serene elegance.
Sherwin Williams Pure White 7005
Pure White SW 7005 with an LRV of 84 has a mix of subtle yellow and gray undertones that makes it appear neutral.
Its lightness brings it close to a pure white with a characteristic of reflecting its surroundings.
Benjamin moore alabaster vs sherwin williams pure white when compared depict a clear variance as the first is one value lighter with an LRV of 85.04 and can appear pink.
While the other depicts a bright white ideal for a modern white look.
Alabaster SW 7008 in contrast to the above colors is a more muted white with an LRV of 82 that feels warm and soft.
You can choose BM alabaster for a subtly radiant warmth of pink, SW pure white for a balanced look and SW alabaster for its inviting embrace.
Benjamin Moore Steam AF-15
BM Steam AF-15 has an LRV of 84.2 with undertones of beige and gray that gives it a pearly white glow.
It has a balance of coolness and warmth that feels refined and graceful.
Between Benjamin Moore steam vs Sherwin Williams alabaster, the latter has a warmer off white appearance due to its LRV of 82.
On the other hand, BM Steam has a more stable profile that works without feeling too icy.
Now if you want something more luminescent, Benjamin Moore Alabaster 876 or 129 with its LRV of 85.04 is the perfect choice as it depicts a clean aesthetic that will suit modern looks.
You can go with BM Steam for more consistent balance in your space or choose Alabaster SW 7008 for a comforting vibe.
| Color | Color Family | LRV | Undertone | Warm or Cool | Hex Value | RGB | Lighting |
| Greek Villa SW 7551 | White | 84 | Yellow, gray and beige | Warm | #F0ECE2 | 240, 236, 226 | Cool or northern light makes it appear soft white Warm or southern light makes it glow with more warmth and creaminess |
| BM White Dove OC-17 | White | 83.16 | Yellow and gray | Warm | #F0EDE4 | 240, 237, 228 | Cool or northern light makes it look soft neutral white Warm or southern light elevates its warmth by making it appear creamier |
| BM Swiss Coffee OC-45 | White | 81.91 | Gray, yellow and green | Warm | #EDEAE0 | 237, 234, 224 | Cool or northern light balances the warmth to make it a polished white Warm or southern light gives it a comforting warmth |
| BM Seapearl OC-19 | White | 76.43 | Cool gray, beige and green | Warm | #E8E3D8 | 232, 227, 216 | Cool or northern light gives it a gentle cool gray look It becomes a creamy beige in warm or southern light |
| BM Calm OC-22 | White | 75.83 | Purple, gray, brown | Cool | #E6E4DF | 230, 228, 223 | It looks cool gray in cool or northern light Warm or southern light pulls out its purple or lavender hues, sometimes brown |
| BM Simply White OC-117 | White | 89.52 | Slight yellow | Warm | #F7F4EB | 247, 244, 235 | A polished true white in cool or northern lighting Warm or southern light makes it feel more creamy |
| Pure White SW 7005 | White | 84 | Hints of yellow and gray | Warm | #EDECE6 | 237, 236, 230 | Cool or northern light makes it look clean white It takes on a subtle creaminess in warm or southern light |
| BM Steam AF-15 | White | 84.2 | Beige with a hint of gray | Balanced | #F0EEE5 | 240, 238, 229 | Cool or northern light gives it a soft white glow A clean depth of ivory or subtle creaminess in warm or southern light |
Benjamin Moore Alabaster VS Sherwin Williams Alabaster: What is the conversation about?
I wondered if others faced the same issues regarding the choice between Benjamin Moore Alabaster vs Sherwin Williams Alabaster and went about unearthing what people said online.
A Reddit user shared that they had a miscommunication with their painter for an alabaster color for their new house.
They expressed that “we had to really dig to actually learn that there’s a BM version” since Sherwin Williams Alabaster was a more commonly known choice.
A reliable advice I found helpful through a comment was to “always provide the color number in addition to the name, manufacturer, and sheen.”
And another user mentioned that, “The only reliable way to compare paint colors is under daylight but then they can look vastly different under artificial light.”
Since the temperature of natural light can change, a redditor said that “with white, its appearance is heavily impacted by the environment around it.” This was an issue that this user faced as their walls pulled green or yellow until they used brighter 3000 vs 2700k lights.
A redditor on the same thread mentioned that they had a home with SW Alabaster trim and they “lovingly call it smokers white” since it has yellow undertones.
A redditor highlights the regular mistakes homeowners make by relying on online sources in place of personally examining physical samples by saying “…google sw alabaster isnt remotely the same as sw alabaster in real life.”
On account of a Benjamin Moore Alabaster review, a user expressed “I love BM Alabaster…calming, sophisticated, & luxurious all baked in one.”
Another suggested that OP should explore accent walls, furnishings and shadows in the home since these affect the nuance of white. According to the user “I have a similar color in my house called Atrium white…” which they consider unique with a beautiful pink hue.
What Colors Coordinate With BM Alabaster and SW Alabaster?
To work with whites like Benjamin Moore Alabaster versus Sherwin Williams Alabaster, you must consider colors that go well with them.
With that in mind, I set the task to figure out which looked best to my friend. The place was hers afterall!
She expressed that having official color combinations to work with was a godsend and we found quite a collection provided by Benjamin Moore.
I advise that you stick with a specific color and code with Benjamin Moore Alabaster to avoid any confusion or mistakes.
We had an easier time with Sherwin Williams Alabaster 7008 since the pick of coordinating colors was officially limited.
This does not mean that you cannot find others that suit your taste.
So sample and choose what pleases you.
Now let us first tackle BM Alabaster!
Coordinating Colors for Benjamin Moore Alabaster
We went with Benjamin Moore Alabaster OC-129 and its official color combinations BM Calm OC-22 and BM Baked Terra Cotta 1202.
These two colors blend with BM alabaster that has an LRV of 85.04 as highlighted accents that form a soft contrasting warmth.
The polished warm off white of BM Calm OC-22 has an LRV of 75.83 with grayish lavender undertones which soothes the mood.
It makes a delicate combination with BM alabaster as its lavender stands out more as vanities and cabinets.
BM Baked Terra Cotta 1202 carries a sophisticated depth of orange and brown.
It makes a bold and moody accent with its LRV of 20.93 which draws the eye given the elegant yet clean visual it conveys.
It worked as an accent wall plus shelves that made my friend’s bedroom whisper in rosy pink coziness.
CHOOSE ANY ONE TABLE
| BM Alabaster OC-129 Coordinating Colors | BM Alabaster 876Coordinating Colors | BM Atrium White OC-145Coordinating Colors | BM Atrium White PM-13Coordinating Colors |
| Calm OC-22LRV: 75.83Undertone: Lavender, grayHex: #E6E4DFRGB: 230, 228, 223 | Organdy 1248LRV: 64.37Undertone: Gray, purpleHex: #E0D2D1RGB: 222, 208, 207 | Muslin OC-12LRV: 66.54Undertone: Slight orange, pinkHex: #E2D7C2RGB: 226, 215, 194 | Barren Plain 2111-60LRV: 62.12Undertone: Cool gray, purple, blueHex: #D4CFC9RGB: 212, 207, 201 |
| Baked Terra Cotta 1202LRV: 20.93Undertone: Orange, brownHex: #B36957RGB: 179, 105, 87 | Ocean Floor 1630LRV: 14.13Undertone: Dark blue, grayHex: #60676CRGB: 96, 103, 109 | Aegean Teal 2136-40LRV: 25.13Undertone: Blue, green, grayHex: #71898BRGB: 113, 137, 139 | Gobi Desert 2110-50LRV: 56.08Undertone: Pink, lavender, taupeHex: #D4C2BDRGB: 212, 194, 189 |
| Garlic Bulb 2112-70LRV: 74.46Undertone: Soft smoky grayHex: #E4E2DFRGB: 228, 226, 223 | Marry Me 1289LRV: 71.30Undertone: Creamy peachHex: #F1D6CFRGB: 241, 214, 207 | Elmira White HC-84LRV: 64.67Undertone: Creamy greigeHex: #DBD1C1RGB: 219, 209, 193 | Angelica AF-665LRV: 61.82Undertone: Lavender, gray, beigeHex: #D4CECARGB: 212, 206, 202 |
| Amorous AF-600LRV: 27.37Undertone: Purple, red, grayHex: #928996RGB: 146, 137, 150 | Himalayan Trek 1542LRV: 47.05Undertone: Neutral gray, beigeHex: #BFB9AFRGB: 191, 185, 175 | Tate Olive HC-112LRV: 21.63Undertone: Yellow, green, brownHex: #837E66RGB: 131, 126, 102 | Cherry Wine 2080-30LRV: 15.70Undertone: Cool red, pinkHex: #A74B5BRGB: 167, 75, 91 |
| Color Variations | BM Alabaster OC-129 | BM Alabaster 876 | BM Atrium White OC-145 | BM Atrium White PM-13 |
| Coordinating Color, LRV, Undertone, Hex Code, RGB | Calm OC-22 75.83 Lavender and gray #E6E4DF 230, 228, 223 | Organdy 1248 64.37 Gray, purple #E0D2D1 222, 208, 207 | Muslin OC-12 66.54 Slight orange, pink #E2D7C2 226, 215, 194 | Barren Plain 2111-60 62.12 Cool gray, purple and blue #D4CFC9 212, 207, 201 |
| Coordinating Color, LRV, Undertone, Hex Code, RGB | Baked Terra Cotta 1202 20.93 Orange and Brown #B36957 179, 105, 87 | Ocean Floor 1630 14.13 Dark blue and gray #60676C 96, 103, 109 | Aegean Teal 2136-40 25.13 Blue, green and gray #71898B 113, 137, 139 | Gobi Desert 2110-50 56.08 Pink, lavender, taupe #D4C2BD 212, 194, 189 |
| Coordinating Color, LRV, Undertone, Hex Code, RGB | Garlic Bulb 2112-70 74.46 Soft smoky gray #E4E2DF 228, 226, 223 | Marry Me 1289 71.3 Creamy peach #F1D6CF 241, 214, 207 | Elmira White HC-84 64.67 Creamy greige #DBD1C1 219, 209, 193 | Angelica AF-665 61.82 Lavender, gray, beige #D4CECA 212, 206, 202 |
| Coordinating Color, LRV, Undertone, Hex Code, RGB | Amorous AF-600 27.37 Purple, red, gray #928996 146, 137, 150 | Himalayan Trek 1542 47.05 Neutral gray, beige #BFB9AF 191, 185, 175 | Tate Olive HC-112 21.63 Yellow, green, brown #837E66 131, 126, 102 | Cherry Wine 2080-30 15.7 Cool red, pink #A74B5B 167, 75. 91 |
Coordinating Colors for Sherwin Williams Alabaster
The official coordinating colors for Alabaster SW 7008 are Townhall Tan SW 7690 and Dakota Wheat SW 9023.
The colors hug Sherwin Williams alabaster with a bold warmth that equally adds a classic and cozy vibe when used together.
Townhall Tan SW 7690 has an LRV between 42 – 43, that can work on the interior as well as exterior.
It will give you a welcome earthiness with its beige and yellow undertones that sometimes flash pink.
Its warmth as an accent piece inside my friend’s east facing bedroom which has helped elevate the coziness against the natural wood.
Dakota Wheat SW 9023 with its LRV of 54 provides an almost golden glow against Alabaster SW 7008 that has an LRV of 82.
The south facing kitchen with Dakota Wheat lower cabinets manifests a sometimes bold, sometimes heartwarming tender radiance that I can’t get enough of.
| Color | Townhall Tan SW 7690 | Dakota Wheat SW 9023 |
| Color Family | Yellow | Yellow |
| LRV | 42 | 54 |
| Undertone | Earthy beige and warm yellow with pink hues | Yellow beige, orange and earthy hues |
| Warm/Cool | Warm | Warm |
| Hex Value | #C3AA8C | #E1BD8E |
| RGB | 195, 170, 140 | 225, 189, 142 |
| Best Use | Exterior, wall, accent, cabinets, trim, bedroom, living room, entryway, shelves, bathroom, kitchen | Accent, living room, bedroom, kitchen and dining room, hallway, cabinets and vanities |
When To Choose Benjamin Moore Alabaster VS Sherwin Williams Alabaster?
I consider Benjamin Moore Alabaster vs Sherwin Williams Alabaster to be ideal whites that can warm up the look of any home.
Note that you must place a special focus on knowing the lighting of your space, then shadows plus design and decor you want to incorporate into it.
There is no better alabaster, only the question of personal taste.
Whether you go with Benjamin Moore or Sherwin Williams alabaster, the stakes lie on what charms you best.
So consider, then always sample with light and choose what is best for you.
If the task of picking one seems too daunting, let me help guide you with the following discussion.
Choose BM Alabaster
For a warm off white that feels polished and elegant, you can go with Benjamin Moore alabaster OC-129.
It will lighten up the mood of your space with its LRV of 85.04 without becoming buttery.
This is the ideal white if you don’t want your living room, bedroom or bathroom to take on a dingy vibe.
This neutral soft white can fit transitional, contemporary or modern designs and pairs best with warm accents.
It will open up narrow rooms with ample lighting and will provide a peachy warmth that will make your space feel cozier.
If you prefer something more closer to Benjamin Moore Alabaster Sherwin William equivalent, you can opt for Pure White SW 7005, Cold Foam SW 9504, and others.
Choose SW Alabaster
You can choose Sherwin Williams alabaster 7008 for its clean tranquility.
It widens up any space with a light soft white due to its LRV of 82.
This is the perfect off white to bring warmth to your home if you don’t mind the subtle yellow that elevates its creaminess in warm light.
The neutral balance of this white suits farmhouse, transitional or traditional homes, especially with earthy accents.
You can work it as a cohesive whole house color since it avoids looking dirty in low light.
Note that it compliments bright and neutral hues as trim, molding or cabinets to offer a soft contrast.
In case you would like a Sherwin Williams Alabaster Benjamin Moore equivalent, there are Swiss Coffee OC 45, Dune White 968 and more here.
Conclusion
So far we have explored the differences of Benjamin Moore alabaster vs Sherwin Williams alabaster by looking at their specific details.
We have studied their LRVs, undertones, lighting and so on to understand how they appear inside a home to make it a cozy retreat.
These warm off whites deliver a soft ambiance while varying in tone as one SW alabaster appears creamy while the other BM alabaster appears pinkish.
Along with this, we have also seen close whites that can substitute them plus colors that they can best complement with.
Do consider opening the link that leads to their known alternatives to widen your net so you may find the best white for your home.
With that, I leave you with a suggestion that you must and you should recognize the lighting situation of your home to sample first before committing to any white color.
FAQs on Benjamin Moore Alabaster VS Sherwin Williams Alabaster
Is Benjamin Moore Alabaster the same as Sherwin Williams Alabaster?
Benjamin Moore Alabaster and Sherwin Williams Alabaster are not the same. They may have the same names and even the same look on a virtual screen, but their LRVs and undertones differ greatly. BM Alabaster is not one color under Benjamin Moore as there are two. One, Alabaster OC-129 and two, Alabaster 876 that have the same pinkish hue with an LRV of 85.04. While Alabaster SW 7008 is a singular color under Sherwin Willimas with a creamy appearance carrying an LRV of 82.
Does Benjamin Moore Alabaster look pink?
Benjamin Moore Alabaster 876 or OC-129 do look pink. This peachy hue emerges under certain conditions of lighting and environment as BM alabaster generally has a soft white appearance due to its high LRV of 85.04. You will find that in certain cool lighting the pink note gives your walls a faint blushing glow, especially surrounded by earthy or organic decor. It is the ideal white for one who does not want their space to carry the dinginess of yellow.
Does Sherwin Williams Alabaster look dingy?
Alabaster SW 7008 can look dingy in very dark spaces. Commonly, Sherwin Williams alabaster has a balanced hue of yellow and gray that keeps it a soft white or subtle beige. It has a high LRV of 82 that makes it a bright white under abundant light and can even warm up your home in cozy lighting. You need to avoid pairing it with stark whites as the contrast of color will make it look dull and less polished. Although it can hold its own and appear soft white in shadowy spaces, it needs good artificial lighting or sunlight to keep it from becoming dingy.
Does Sherwin Williams Alabaster look grey?
Sherwin Williams Alabaster 7008 can indeed look grey under certain lighting. It is a warm off white with an LRV of 82 and gray yellow undertones. The gray of this soft off white can emerge in very cool lighting of LED 4000k to 5000k bulbs or shadowy environments. It commonly does not take on a deep gray look but usually has a subtle greige touch to it, especially when placed beside very bright or crisp whites.
